• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

MMA Payout

The Business of Combat Sports

  • Home
  • MMA
    • UFC
    • Bellator
    • One
    • PFL
  • Boxing
  • Legal
  • Ratings
  • Payouts
  • Attendance
  • Gate

Judge rules in New York’s favor, dismisses Zuffa lawsuit

March 31, 2015 by Jason Cruz 7 Comments

On Tuesday, Judge Kimba Wood granted New York’s Motion for Summary Judgment and denied Zuffa’s Motion for Summary Judgment thus ending (for now) the company’s legal battle to strike down New York’s law prohibiting professional mixed martial arts in the state.

Essentially, Judge Wood stated that Zuffa lacked “standing” as a plaintiff as there was no “injury in fact” and it was “merely speculative.” Since the Court determined that there was no “imminent injury” in the evidence presented, it sided with New York. Thus the remaining claim that the New York statute was unconstitutionally vague as well as a similar challenge to the state liquor law were dismissed.

Two key points made by Judge Wood here was that Zuffa had to establish an “injury in fact.” It held that there were no “specific facts” provided by Zuffa to survive the motion for summary judgment. Secondly, the Court stressed that standing must be determined at the commencement of the suit. Essentially, the Court let it be known that anything that occurred after the filing in November 2011, could not be utilized as evidence to prove standing now.

In her opinion issued on Tuesday, she indicated that if Zuffa wants to re-file based on events that may have occurred since the lawsuit was filed in November 2011, it may be better served to do this in state court rather than federal court.

The Court did not rule on a Motion to Strike filed by New York which it sought to preclude some of Zuffa’s evidence since it already had ruled in New York’s favor.

(h/t: Jim Genia)

Payout Perspective:

We had predicted that this may have been a likely outcome. In its moving papers, New York had stressed the standing argument which would allow an “out” for the Court to dismiss the case without a further need for ruling on the merits. Yes, that’s a Zuffa view of the New York strategy (of course, a more Zuffa view would be its press release announcing the decision). It’s also a very good one and one that courts tend to look for if the issues either become convoluted, a toss-up or they just don’t think that the claims were that strong. We’re not saying any of those was the reason for the ruling Tuesday. But, standing is a necessary requirement in bringing claims. Essentially Con Law 101. But, there were legitimate arguments set forth by Zuffa which addressed the reasons why it had a right to bring the lawsuit.

At this point, it’s too early to know whether Zuffa will appeal or focus its efforts on lobbying for an MMA bill in Albany. MMA Payout will have more on this and keep you posted.

Filed Under: Featured, legal, New York, regulation, UFC, Zuffa

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. saldathief says

    March 31, 2015 at 7:06 pm

    hahahah I forgot about this lawsuit, at least the UFC attorneys are making real money bahahahha

    Reply
  2. tops E says

    March 31, 2015 at 8:01 pm

    Hahahahaha…antitrust next? hahahahaha

    Reply
  3. anti trolls says

    March 31, 2015 at 8:06 pm

    You two are a couple of donks

    Reply
  4. d says

    March 31, 2015 at 8:39 pm

    A pair of mutated retards as well.

    Who cares about this ruling, the only one that really matters is the one where it is legalized which will get down by the end of the year.

    Reply
  5. saldathief says

    April 1, 2015 at 11:48 am

    hahah im sure all the girls at zuffa really fucking care!!!!!!! only a retard like D wouldn’t care. but D dosnt understand anything but google x box and masterbation! hahahaha oh well they dont have a show big enough for msg yet hahahah

    Reply
  6. d says

    April 1, 2015 at 2:08 pm

    Hahahaha.

    Sal only cares about Arum’s crusty dick and someone changing his shit dripping diapers. He’s just a retarded, homosexual boxing welfare to work troll.

    Reply
  7. SashaConstantine says

    April 8, 2015 at 3:08 pm

    The giggle-tards who post their idiotic comments criticizing Zuffa and their struggle to become legal in New York must not know that they can now rent Dumb and Dumber Too. Yes, you can now watch two morons living out your life’s dream over and over again instead of posting ignorant remarks about subjects you know very little, if anything about, except of course “masturbation” which other than not knowing how to spell it, you are experts in the field.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Featured

UFC 334 attendance, gate, and bonuses

IBF seeks to stay discovery in Opetaia lawsuit

TKO announce Q3 earnings

UFC 333 bonuses

FBI seeking no-bid contract with the UFC

Court denies Top Rank’s Motion to Dismiss in Keane case

Archives

MMA Payout Follow

MMAPayout

😂

Mina Kimes @minakimes

Asians still allowed to wear leather jackets or is it too soon?

NFL Live from Baltimore today

Retweet on Twitter MMA Payout Retweeted

If this weekend proved anything it's that fighters at large have very little idea how fights are scored.

Retweet on Twitter MMA Payout Retweeted

#BREAKING: Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo and U.S. Bank hit by nationwide outage, users report.

Retweet on Twitter MMA Payout Retweeted

Dana White claims he wants ‘nothing to do with politics’ while appearing on Fox News

The Professor in the Garden #And1

Barstool Sports @barstoolsports

THAT WHITE BOY IS COLD

RYAN MOESCH DROPPED THAT MAN

Copyright © 2026 · MMA Payout: The Business of Combat Sports