• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

MMA Payout

The Business of Combat Sports

  • Home
  • MMA
    • UFC
    • Bellator
    • One
    • PFL
  • Boxing
  • Legal
  • Ratings
  • Payouts
  • Attendance
  • Gate

Top Rank seeks to dismiss claims in Garcia’s lawsuit

October 20, 2014 by Jason Cruz Leave a Comment

This past Friday, attorneys for Top Rank Boxing filed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings in U.S. District Court in Nevada seeking to dismiss a bulk of boxer Mikey Garcia’s lawsuit.

Garcia’s lawsuit was originally filed in Riverside County (CA) Superior Court.  Top Rank lawyer’s removed the case to Federal Court in Nevada via a procedural rule allowing such transfers based on the lawsuit dealing with federal legal issues (i.e., Muhammad Ali Act).  Garcia alleged that his promotional contract with Top Rank violated California law and the state’s strong public policy to protect California-based boxers from being taken advantage of by promoters and managers.  In the lawsuit, 3 of California’s claims relate to violations of California law.  Garcia claims that the promotional contract with Top Rank violated California’s Boxing Act and Professional Boxing Rules and California Labor Code section 2855.  He also claimed it was a violation of California’s restraint on competition.

Top Rank has moved for the court to make a judgment to dismiss Garcia’s claims based on the boxer’s claims under state law in California.  Essentially, Top Rank argues that Garcia entered into contracts with the promotion that state that the contract was governed by the state of Nevada.   Thus, any claims Garcia makes that violate California law should be dismissed since the contract is based on Nevada law.

Basically, Top Rank argues that despite the fact that Garcia is a resident of California and has had events where he fought in California; the contract dispute should be governed by the state of Nevada.  As such, Garcia’s legal claims related to violations of California law should be dismissed.

Top Rank argues several reasons why Nevada law should prevail under the terms of the contract. Namely, the terms of the contract dictate it, Garcia fought in Nevada and his manager does business in Nevada.  Also, Nevada law would not contradict California law.  It also cited the fact that prior boxing contracts with choice of law provisions are typically enforced by boxing commissions and courts.  Notably, it cited Robert Guerrero’s lawsuit against Golden Boy Promotions in which Guerrero lost his legal battle allowing the parties to settle their case in New York per the terms of the contract.  Guerrero argued that Top Rank did not use the   appropriate CSAC forms and the case should be heard in California.

Payout Perspective:

The motion to dismiss a portion of Garcia’s lawsuit was not surprising.  The legal strategy here was that Top Rank transferred the lawsuit to federal court and out of California where the state laws would seemingly favor the boxer.  Once the case was in Nevada, it sought to dismiss the California-specific claims.  Certainly, prior cases reflect the fact that Top Rank had the right, based on the contract, to seek out the appropriate governing law.  Whether or not the Court will grant the motion this time is another issue.

MMA Payout will keep you posted.

Filed Under: boxing, contracts, Golden Boy, legal, Top Rank

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Featured

UFC 334 attendance, gate, and bonuses

IBF seeks to stay discovery in Opetaia lawsuit

TKO announce Q3 earnings

UFC 333 bonuses

FBI seeking no-bid contract with the UFC

Court denies Top Rank’s Motion to Dismiss in Keane case

Archives

MMA Payout Follow

MMAPayout

Tony Wroten

Cousins with Vince Carter & Tracy McGrady @VinceAndTmac

The best Shammgod moves that God Shammgod has seen pulled off in a game? He goes with Tony Wroten and @russwest44 🔥🔥🔥🔥

🎥: @Ballislife

Retweet on Twitter MMA Payout Retweeted

Y'all complaining about a server being down. Meanwhile ya parents was at the mall in '98 handing out fades in front of a GameStop on a Monday night at 11:58 PM because somebody jumped the line. If you wanted to be the first one to play the game you had to REALLY want it

My high school football coach told us if there's one muscle you have to work out in the weight room, it's your neck. This just reminded me of that:

All Elite Wrestling @AEW

The Kasper Brothers make a DEVASTATING statement in their AEW in-ring debut! 😳

Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS & HBO Max!

Broken neck?....Not only landing on your neck, but the other dude falls on you with his full body weight.

Drainmaker @TheDrainmaker

THE KASPER BROTHERS ALREADY TERRIFYING DUDES IN AEW.

KILLED THAT POOR GUY. 😭

Retweet on Twitter MMA Payout Retweeted

UFC signee Igor Cavalcanti (14-2) has been suspended by NSAC for a positive test for 19-Norandrosterone connected to his #DWCS win

Cavalcanti's team tells me it stems from knee injections prior to the DWCS offer and that he had disclosed use. Story headed to @MMAjunkie

Copyright © 2026 · MMA Payout: The Business of Combat Sports